For the two straight seasons, the WHAT? Softball ended their season short of a League Night Title. After concluding the 2011 season with a 1-2 playoff record, the WHAT? Softball finished with a 14-26 league play record.
The WHAT? Softball faced many challenges due to injuries that impacted the team on the field. From Matt Mitchell, Clark Collins, Chuck Breucher to Justin Yonke, the Squad lost many game-changing players who were temporally out of the line-up.
There was too much inconsistency on offense. They lost too many two-run games. After losing eight of their last nine games, they never returned to .500 for the remainder of the season.